Our 9 Favorite Mary Janes From Sustainable Shoe Companies (2024)
The Good Trade editors endorse products we’ve personally researched, tested, and genuinely love. Learn more about our methodology and business model here.
We’ve worn and loved shoes from sustainable brands for a decade — these are our top picks for Mary Janes that look great and are good for the planet, at a range of prices.
Mary Janes are not only sweetly nostalgic and feminine — they’re also a perfectly practical solution for spring and summer dressing. Mary Janes became a schoolyard staple because of that versatility. They’re great for looking put together or playing kickball at recess (whatever that may translate to in your adult life!).
We’re big fans of MJs that are sustainably made, particularly when natural fabrics are involved for durability and breathability throughout repeat wears. While all eyes are on Mary Janes right now, this timeless shoe is a staple shape that will outlive the trend cycle — and what’s more sustainable than that?
Why consider sustainable footwear?
Footwear production is responsible for 1.4% of global greenhouse emissions. And, on the other end of your shoe’s lifecycle, consider this: Over 22 billion shoes end up in landfills in the US every year. Pair that environmental impact with the unfair labor practices that are often used in fast fashion production, and you can see why sustainability in footwear is so important.
Sustainable footwear companies use natural, non-toxic materials that are better for us and for the environment. These better-quality materials also equate to longer-lasting shoes which saves you money and prevents more waste from piling up in the landfill.
Our criteria:
We’ve personally worn, researched, and corresponded with the top sustainable footwear brands for the past 10 years. These are our picks for Mary Janes that use ethical and sustainable manufacturing practices — and look great — at a variety of price points. This piece is regularly updated with emerging brands that meet the standards below.
- ECO-FRIENDLY/SUSTAINABLE | All of the shoe brands on this list use sustainable production practices and prioritize natural and recycled/upcycled materials for a better product for you and the earth.
- COMFORTABLE | We’ve researched, worn, and/or scoured hundreds of customer reviews for each of these shoe brands so you can trust they’re comfy and supportive for all-day wear.
- AFFORDABLE | Sustainable shoes can be an investment so we’ve included options at both ends of the spectrum, so you can find something within budget.
Can’t get enough of stylish, eco-conscious shoes? Check out our guides to sustainable shoe brands, sneakers and tennis shoes, boots, and sandals.
1. VIVAIA
Best For | Budget-friendly
Price Range | $79–$97
Fashion meets function with VIVAIA. Their sustainable shoes prioritize eco-responsibility and functionality, making them the ideal everyday shoe. Beyond comfort, they feature moisture-repellent and breathable antimicrobial soles to keep you feeling fresh all day. Plus, their customizable straps ensure a tailored fit, and their double arches support you through a long day of walking. Whether you’re looking for stylish work shoes or comfortable flats for traveling or romping through your errands, this is the shoe for you. And they’re machine washable! What can’t they do?
Customer review | “Obsessed with my Mary Jane Claire walkers. Finally a cute, supportive comfortable shoe that doesn’t look geriatric. I am usually a size 8 in most shoes, ordered these in a 8.5 and they are perfect. Lots of compliments!” – Rosemary C. (Read more reviews.)
2. Rothy’s
Best For | On-trend options
Price Range | $159
All the fashion editors I follow are obsessed with their Rothy’s Mary Janes. The coolest person you know is wearing these to run their errands, go out to dinner, and meet the in-laws. Their signature square-toed Mary Jane is a laidback version of the classic. The machine-washable, flexible knit is both durable and washable. Rothy’s is also a pioneer in sustainable manufacturing. They were the world’s first shoe manufacturer to receive both LEED Gold and TRUE Zero Waste Platinum certification. Made from recycled, natural, or renewable materials, they collect ocean-bound marine plastic from within 30 miles of coastlines to prevent pollution and turn trash into the shoes we know and love.
Customer review | “Sparks joy: These are stunning and so comfy. There’s no break in time whatsoever. Pretty sure these are like Pokemon. Gotta catch em all.” – Kara M. (Read more reviews.)
3. Small Lot
Best For | Artsy, thick soles
Price Range | $98–$156
The cost-per-wear on these Small Lot Mary Janes is impressive. Priced at under $100 and made to last, Small Lot shoes are simple but classic — so they’ll never go out of style. They’re made of premium upcycled and organic cotton canvas and a natural rubber sole. Natural dye creates a rainbow of color combinations, so there’s a pair for everyone. They come in a lightweight classic style and a trendy lug-sole style. Take your pick! You can’t go wrong.
4. Suzanne Rae
Best For | Luxury looks
Price Range | $495–$550
Cool girl Suzanne Rae makes sustainable, splurge-worthy styles that you’ll be adding to your wishlist. Inspired by feminist theory, their clothes are about self-expression “for the wearer’s own enhanced experience and not for the gaze of others.” They’ve been making heeled Mary Janes since 2017, and they’ve become the signature Suzanne Rae piece. With a square toe, comfortable block heel, and bold designs, they’re an iconic Mary Jane. Now, Suzanne Rae makes a variety of vintage-inspired styles and takes on the Mary Jane. Made between New York and Italy, they also promote slow fashion by encouraging the investment of few but quality pieces. Add these Mary Janes to your capsule wardrobe.
5. Reformation
Best For | Strappy, seasonal wear
Price Range | $268
The favorite of the wedding guest, bridal shower, graduation, and Sunday brunch outfit, Reformation is the first store you think of when you think of style and sustainability. They’ve been climate-neutral since 2015, aiming to be climate-positive by 2025, and have shaken up the fashion industry for almost a decade with their innovative processes and trend-forward collections. I remember how excited I was when they first released their shoe collection. Their strappy block heels have become a staple in my rotation. Their new Mary Janes are a flat version of the same celebrated style, offering even more wearable cuteness for your closet.
6. Alohas
Best For | Sophisticated shapes
Price Range | $160–$266
Euro summer calling? So are Euro shoes. Alohas are handcrafted in Barcelona, producing on-trend styles in a sustainable way. They’ve garnered a loyal fanbase for their innovative approach to style and sustainability. Working on a pre-order and on-demand system means no wasted materials, combatting overproduction. To make their leather styles, they work with the Leather Working Group to find ethically sourced leather from environmentally certified suppliers. For their vegan options, they use plant-based materials for cute and cruelty-free shoe options in every style. Their brand-new ballet flat styles include a range of Mary Janes in sophisticated colors and timeless shapes. I’ll be adding them all to my Pinterest board.
Customer review | “Even better than expected! Quality & design are amazing – higher than the known high standards of Alohas products.” – Eleni Korre (Read more reviews.)
7. Zou Xou
Best For | Classic styles
Price Range | $203–$295
Old-fashioned craftspersonship meets modern styles at Zou Xou. Functional and fun, they make inspired styles that are built to last. Zou Xou is on a mission to make sensible shoes sustainable and stylish. Their leather Mary Janes come in funky shades and bold patterns, so there’s something for every person’s style. Handmade in Argentina, their on-demand and small-batch production cycle creates a slower, ethical process. They also keep an ethical workplace by ensuring a safe, comfortable environment for their artisans, who also have the freedom to establish their own wages and work hours.
Customer review | “Beautiful color and amazing craftsmanship. Comfortable out of the box. The tortoiseshell buckle is a lovely addition.” – Victoria S. (Read more reviews.)
8. Alterre
Best For | Day-to-night
Price Range | $180–$230
A shoe for every occasion, Alterre Mary Janes feature a removable strap (or bow!) that you can take off to transform them into ballet flats. The day-to-night essential you’ve been looking for. Get all-day comfort with their cushioned soles while getting a small lift with their recycled heel. Whether you’re drawn to classic styles or bold prints and bows, Alterre’s Mary Janes are a great pick for daytime to date night.
Customer review | “Nice low heel, comfortable, and very versatile. Thanks for the great idea of changing straps and shoes.”—Greg M. (Read more reviews.)
9. Mar Soreli
Best For | Artisanal craft
Price Range | $165
From the same people who founded the iconic lingerie brand Cosabella, Mar Soreli makes Italian craftspersonship accessible. They bridge the gap between customers seeking ethical shoes with a classic feel and small artisans with historically limited access to international brands. Made with high-quality materials and classic styles, their shoes are well made without compromising style. Made with bright colors and a hand-sewn fabric, these unique Mary Janes will make you feel like the main character.
Customer review | “Shoes are beautiful and very comfortable for my sore feet.” – Mollie W. (Read more reviews.)
Featured image is from Small Lot
