9 Best Organic Cotton Mattress Protectors In 2023
The Good Trade editors endorse products we’ve personally researched, tested, and genuinely love. Learn more about our methodology and business model here.
An organic mattress is no small investment, which is why we’re big believers in extending the life of your mattress with a protective layer between your mattress and your sheets.
The good news — mattress protectors keep your mattress clean from dust mites, allergens, spilled drinks, pet or kiddo accidents, and sexy-time adventures. Just throw your protector in the wash and you’re good as new, with no lingering odor or dampness. The bad news — traditional mattress protectors are generally made from polyester, vinyl or PVC, phthalates, and butane rubber, and are treated with chemicals known to cause harmful off-gassing. 🤯
There is a safer way to protect your mattress. Our editors have researched, tested, and vetted the best organic cotton mattress protectors certified by GOTS or OEKO-TEX so everyone in the family rests safely and soundly. While you’re giving your bedroom an eco-friendly boost, check out our guides to organic mattresses, organic mattress toppers, and organic pillows.
Best Overall | Most Affordable | Best Waterproof
1. PlushBeds
Organic Materials | GOTS & USDA certified organic cotton
Features | Waterproof, silent, machine washable, biodegradable packaging
Price of Queen Protector | $149
PlushBeds, a family-owned company, makes building a sustainable home simpler. Its organic waterproof mattress protector is GOTS certified and made locally in the company’s DTC factory in California. In addition to cotton jersey on the top side and skirting of this mattress protector, the protector also touts a nontoxic, breathable polyurethane underside. With numerous sizing options (including split and sofa beds!), it’s the perfect fit (pun intended) for every mattress.
2. Avocado
Organic Materials | GOTS certified organic cotton
Features | Handmade, plastic-free, machine washable
Price of Queen Protector | $299
Certified B Corp Avocado’s mattress protectors are made with GOTS certified organic cotton—including this organic waterproof option! Soft, absorbent, and breathable, it’s a natural and carbon-neutral alternative free from vinyls, PVCs, or chemical finishes. Our founder uses Avocado’s protector for her baby’s crib mattress — and wow does it protect the mattress from liquid explosions of all kinds. 💩 Straight from fair trade farms to your bedroom, a portion of each order gives back via 1% for the Planet.
*SAVE 10% on your first purchase WITH CODE GOODTRADE
3. Boll & Branch
Organic Materials | GOTS-certified organic cotton
Features | Padded with breathable organic cotton, secure elastic binding
Price of Queen Protector | $198
Sensitive sleepers, you’re in for a treat with Boll & Branch’s organic mattress protector. Each non-waterproof protector combines GOTS certified organic cotton, natural fiberfill, and an OEKO-TEX certified treatment to fight against bacteria and allergens. This breathable barrier will keep you safe and soft all night long. Like all Boll & Branch products—including sheets, which we personally reviewed—all materials are sourced responsibly and produced ethically.
4. Happsy
Organic Materials | Certified organic cotton
Features | 15 inch pocket, nontoxic waterproof layer
Price of Queen Protector | $119
Happsy believes safety and sustainability can go hand-in-hand, especially in our homes. This organic mattress protector brings us a step closer with the use of certified organic cotton—and a non-toxic waterproof barrier for anytime mistakes happen. The team is committed to giving back too, supporting environmental causes via 1% for the Planet.
5. Brentwood Home
Organic Materials | GOTS certified organic cotton
Features | Fits mattresses 6-16 inches, noise-free waterproof layer
Price of Queen Protector | $139
To protect mattresses up to 16” high, Brentwood Home’s dependable, resistant, and fitted Waterproof Mattress Protector is a worthwhile investment. With a super-thin polyurethane film sandwiched between two plush layers of GOTS certified organic cotton inside and out, you’ll enjoy a fresher, cooler, and safer night’s sleep. Similar to Brentwood’s line of mattresses and bedding, this eco-friendly and ethically made product is made to last.
*Save 10% on your first purchase using code GOODTRADE
6. Coyuchi
Organic Materials | GOTS certified organic cotton
Features | Two inches quilted square finish, 15 inch pocket, full elastic band
Price of Queen Protector | $298
Crafted with organic cotton, Coyuchi’s organic mattress pad is woven in India and finished with two-inch quilted squares and a 220 percale covering. This absorbent protector will keep your bed safe from spills, stains, and everything in between, and needs just one wash a month. Coyuchi’s products are GOTS certified, Fair Trade Certified, and equipped with MADE SAFE seal.
7. Saatva
Organic Materials | GOTS certified organic cotton
Features | Extra wide elastic band, fits mattresses up to 16 inches high
Price of Queen Protector | $225
Saatva’s Fair Trade Certified mattress pad helps improve your sleep and the environment—and ensures safe working conditions for employees. Not only is the protector itself made from organic cotton, but so are the side panels, secured with an elastic band. Though this mattress protector is not waterproof, you can depend on the ultimate protection, 300-thread count comfort, and deep fit, so it won’t move as you may do throughout the night.
8. Nest Bedding
Organic Materials | 100% cotton
Features | 18 inch pocket depth, five-sided or encasement styles, waterproof protection
Price of Queen Protector | $95
The two-in-one Cooling Cotton Mattress Protector from Nest Bedding is the perfect investment for the longterm yet comfy protection of your mattress. This liquid-proof cotton cover comes in five-sided or encasement styles, and offers a breathable yet waterproof layer of mattress coverage that you can count on. With a deep pocket and coming in Twin through Cal King sizes, you can cover every mattress in your home with this versatile, cooling protector. There’s a reason this product has almost 400 rave reviews!
9. NaturalMat
Organic Materials | GOTS certified organic cotton or wool
Features | Handmade, machine washable
Price of Queen Protector | £110
Gentle to the touch but still optimized for protection, NaturalMat’s mattress protectors are an ideal choice for our UK friends. Crafted with locally sourced materials, each product is chemical-free for as long as you use it, and biodegradable for when you don’t. With two options—a washable wool protector or a waterproof organic cotton protector—you can find the best fit for your mattress and preferred sleep style.
