8 Dreamy Melatonin Supplements With Organic Ingredients
For Your Best Night’s Sleep
Tossing and turning. Staring at the ceiling. Willing yourself to fall—and stay—asleep. We’ve been there. And it’s hard! The good news is, there are natural sleep aids we can turn to for a better night’s rest.
These nine sleep aids and alternatives harness naturally occurring ingredients like melatonin, magnesium, and ashwagandha to calm both body and mind before heading to bed. Melatonin, a horomone that your brain produces in response to darkness, is particularly having a moment in the wide range of gummies, powders, and supplements on the market. (Suggested doses of melatonin are between 0.5 to 5mg, though we suggest talking to your doctor.) While melatonin isn’t necessary to sleep, higher levels in the body have been linked to better quality sleep.
Pair these sleep aids with a solid bedtime routine (and maybe a new mattress), and you’ll get the rest you need in no time. And for something a bit stronger, check out our guide to sustainable and organic CBD.
Best Overall — Megafood
Most Affordable — Rae Wellness
Best Melatonin Alternative — Moon Juice
Ingredients | Melatonin, organic wild blueberry & tart cherry, organic syrup & cane sugar
Ethics | Certified B Corp, organic & natural ingredients, vegan, certified gluten-free, ISO certified production
Price | $17 for 27 servings
Megafood has spent nearly 50 years crafting the highest-quality wellness supplements, all from organic and natural ingredients. In fact, its own manufacturing facility is ISO certified, so ingredients are tested for purity and potency. This vegan, gluten-, and dairy-free formula sends you right to sleep (in a good way), thanks to the 3mg of melatonin and farm-fresh ingredients.
2. Moon Juice
Ingredients | Magnesium, L-theanine, natural fruit extracts & flavors
Ethics | Natural ingredients, 100 percent traceable & sustainably sourced
Price | $42 for 30 servings
When melatonin isn’t helping, sometimes magnesium will! Moon Juice’s Magnesi-Om contains three bioavailable types of magnesium that release slowly to help you wind down. The powder is sweetened with monk fruit and easily dissolves in water (or any drink of choice). As a bonus, it’s known to alleviate PMS symptoms, too! With over 1,000 five-star reviews, it’s worth giving this sustainably sourced sleep aid a try.
Shop Moon Juice
3. Not Pot
Ingredients | Melatonin, CBD hemp extract, vegan gelatin, tapioca
Ethics | Natural & organic ingredients, sustainably sourced, gives back
Price | $30 for 30 servings
Of course, we couldn’t have a sleep aid guide without CBD. That’s where Not Pot comes in. Its CBD gummies combine 3mg of melatonin and 20mg of hemp-derived CBD for the most blissful rest. Plus, it’s vegan, made without artificial flavors and dyes, and gives back to criminal justice reform. No more fits of interrupted sleep with this powerful formula; you’ll easily stay asleep all night long. 2,500+ glowing reviews agree!
Shop Not Pot
Ingredients | Full-spectrum CBD, melatonin, myrcene, terpinolene, hemp extract, coconut oil
Ethics | Vegan, made in the USA, pesticides- and GMO-free
Price | $76 for 30 servings
This non-GMO CBD oil from TerraVita is for those of us who not only need a little help falling asleep but also staying asleep. The combination of full-spectrum CBD with sedating terpenes and melatonin help signal to the brain that it’s time for catching z’s. This is liquid gold. One dropper at bedtime leaves us feeling rested (but not groggy) in the morning. And it actually tastes yummy! Choose from clean grapefruit or indulgent caramel vanilla ice cream flavors and pick your preferred strength dosage from 500mg—2000mg; you’ll be off to dreamland in no time.
Ingredients | Melatonin, organic ashwagandha, organic rice syrup
Ethics | Organic & natural ingredients, vegan
Price | $15 for 20 lozenges
Launched by an herbalist who was tired of sugary sweet supplements, Kindroot blends melatonin and ashwagandha (an adaptogenic) for this effective sleep aid. Supplemented by natural flavors, you’ll enjoy hints of vanilla and lavender as you drift off to your dreams. It’s free of gluten, dairy, dye, and GMOs. We love this option for those who aren’t into pills or powder!
6. HUM Nutrition
Ingredients | Melatonin, vitamin B6, calcium
Ethics | Vegan, natural ingredients, recycled & recyclable packaging
Price | $10 for 30 daily capsules
HUM Nutrition is on a mission to become the best, most reliable nutrition biz in the world—and the team is well on its way. Each formula contains only natural and sustainable ingredients and is then triple-tested for purity and independently verified for potency. The Beauty ZZZZ formula comes with 3mg of melatonin and vitamin B6 to help reset your circadian rhythm. It won’t just help you fall asleep—you’ll stay asleep, wake up refreshed, and repeat.
Shop HUM Nutrition
Ingredients | Melatonin, reishi extract, magnesium, hemp oil, L-theanine
Ethics | Vegan, natural ingredients
Price | $76–$112 for 30 servings
Beam aims to help improve your mental and physical wellbeing with a line of hemp-powered products. Its Dream collection offers you three independently tested ways to snooze: regular capsules, extra strength capsules, and a powder. All contain the same ingredients, just varying forms or doses; the regular capsules contain 3mg of melatonin while the extra strength contains 6mg. If you’re a fan, you can also subscribe to a monthly shipment for 20 percent off. We love the powder: just a half scoop—frothed with warm oat or almond milk 😋 —is the perfect serving about an hour before bed. Save the full scoop for weekends when you can sleep in!
8. Rae Wellness
Ingredients | Melatonin, lemon balm, chamomile, flower extract, L-theanine
Ethics | Vegan, natural ingredients, recyclable packaging, gives back
Price | $15 for 30 servings
You’ve probably seen Rae Wellness taking over the shelves of Target or pharmacies. That’s because these supplements really work—check out the hundreds of positive reviews! Rae’s sleep capsules leverage 3mg of melatonin per serving, along with a natural proprietary blend to promote relaxation and calm your mind. Not only will you get better rest, but you’ll also help do better, too: Rae gives five percent of revenue to Girls, Inc.
Shop Rae Wellness
Featured image is from Beam
The Good Trade editors endorse products we genuinely love. If you end up making a purchase through one of our affiliate links, we may earn a commission. Learn more here.