Puffs, bags, and dark circles won’t stand a chance with these eye patches!

After long days of staring at the computer or restless nights of sleep (we are in a pandemic, after all), our under eyes may be feeling a bit weary. And while we love using the age-old cucumber slices for eye bags and dark circles, there are a number of natural alternatives out there that have us saving our cucumbers for salads. 😉

Whether you’re looking for a morning pick-me-up or are indulging in a stay-at-home spa treatment, check out these natural and organic eye masks from our favorite sustainable beauty brands, including some low- and zero-waste options! If you’re refreshing your whole routine, be sure to check out the best natural and organic skincare brands here.

1. Dieux Skin

Natural & Organic | Reusable patches, sustainable packaging
Ethical | Cruelty-free, ethically made, gives back
Price | $25

Dieux Skin’s Forever Eye Mask may be the last one you’ll ever need—because it’s specifically made to last. These reusable under-eye patches are crafted with 100 percent silicone, so you can use day after day without the waste. Pair with your favorite eye serum or cream, then layer the patches on to help the product sink in. Rinse and repeat as often as you’d like! If the mask is sold out, don’t fret—the brand restocks often!

Shop Dieux Skin

2. 100% PURE

Natural & Organic | 95 percent organic ingredients, plant-based ingredients
Ethical | Cruelty-free, vegan, gives back, sustainable practices
Price | $7/1-pack; $30/5-pack

100% Pure will energize and brighten even the most tired eyes. Made from organic aloe juice and plant cellulose, these de-puffing masks are supplemented with green coffee and yerba mate for a natural caffeine boost. Once you’ve pressed the patches gently into your skin, leave them on until they begin to shrivel—as the hydration is literally transferred to your face! Stock up on five packs at once for a more economical option.

Shop 100% Pure

3. Juice Beauty

Natural & Organic | Certified organic and natural ingredients, sustainable packaging
Ethical | Cruelty-free, gives back, sustainable practices
Price | $10/1-pack

Like all Juice Beauty products, the Instant Eye Lift Algae Mask is crafted with certified organic ingredients. Rather than using cotton pads, which can be sprayed with pesticide, these under-eye masks are made of freeze-dried algae. Simply add a few drops of the Activator Fluid (formulated with organic chamomile, cucumber, and white tea), and you’ll soon see the difference. 

Shop Juice Beauty

4. Loops Beauty

Natural & Organic | Paraben- and sulfate-free, compostable, recyclable packaging
Ethical | Cruelty-free
Price | $20/5-pack

For sensitive skin, we recommend Loops Beauty’s eye masks. Powered by Korean beauty formulas, and tested by dermatologists and model Emily Ratajkowski herself, these hydrating patches will help with dark circles and bags, and they’ll have your under eyes refreshed and restored in less than 15 minutes. While these are single-use, each mask is compostable, and the packaging can be recycled. 

Shop Loops Beauty

5. Milk Makeup

Natural & Organic | Paraben- and sulfate-free, sustainable packaging
Ethical | Cruelty-free, gives back
Price | $22/6-pack

Designed and produced in New York City, Milk Makeup is a leader in clean, cool, and cruelty-free beauty. And Milk’s Cooling Water Eye Patches are a testament to just that: These fabric patches are infused with caffeine, natural seawater, aloe, and lavender to leave your skin feeling calm and circulated. Each box contains six sets, making it an affordable splurge that gives us spa vibes. Puffs no more!

Shop Milk Makeup

6. Pacifica Beauty

Natural & Organic | Natural and plant-based ingredients, paraben- and SLS-free
Ethical | Cruelty-free, recyclable products
Price | $5/1-pack

Pacifica Beauty’s Eye Bright mask unites the ingredients we love most in skin care: Vitamin C, plant-based cellulose, and mineral-rich kelp. Together, each blend will have your under-eye area hydrated and supple within 20 minutes. Once complete, just pat in the remaining serum. As part of Pacifica Beauty’s commitment to sustainability, the brand accepts recyclable and empty products to minimize waste.

Shop Pacifica Beauty

7. Orbit Eye Stones

Natural & Organic | Natural stone, zero waste
Ethical | Certified B Corp, sustainable practices, gives back
Price | $20/1-pack

For a truly zero waste option, check out Orbit Eye Stones via Uncommon Goods, a certified B Corp. These stones are derived from Finnish bedrock more than two billion years old, so it’s safe to say they’ll last a while for you, too! Throw them in the fridge for a few minutes prior to use, and then place on or under your eyes for immediate relief. Talk about easy on the eyes.

Shop Orbit Eye Stones

The Good Trade editors endorse products we genuinely love. If you end up making a purchase through one of our affiliate links, we may earn a commission. Learn more here.