10 Best Natural Eye Creams With Organic Ingredients
The Good Trade editors endorse products we’ve personally researched, tested, and genuinely love. Learn more about our methodology and business model here.
Whether we’re sleep-deprived or in the midst of changing seasons, our eyes can show wear and tear on a daily basis. From puffiness to dark circles to tender skin, our eyes can be afflicted with any number of issues. But there’s still hope for nourished, hydrated skin: a good eye cream.
We’ve found ten organic eye creams and gels that are sure to revive your eyes. Using organic ingredients like rosehip oil, aloe juice, and algae, you can take even better care of your skin in a safe and natural way.
1. 100% PURE
Best For | Puffy eyes
Natural & Organic | Natural & organic ingredients, gluten-free
Price | $29 for 1 oz
If you’re dealing with tired and puffy eyes, 100% PURE’s Coffee Bean Caffeine Eye Cream will revitalize you. Based on a four-week independent clinical study, nearly 100 percent of users saw a reduction of puffiness with continued use and all participants said it improved their skin’s hydration. And we can see why based on its ingredients alone: coffee and green tea to de-puff and brighten and calming vitamin E with rosehip oil to for a moisturized eye area. This eye cream is a fan favorite with five stars and over 4,000 reviews.
Best For | Dark circles
Natural & Organic | Squalane, phytic acid, shea butter
Price | $47 for .5 oz
If you are plugged into the online beauty world, you’ve definitely picked up the buzz around Beautycounter (read our full Beautycounter review here). The California-based brand is known for its rigorous clean beauty standards and commitment to ethical sourcing and environmental responsibility. The Countermatch Eye Rescue Cream packs a powerful punch against puffiness and undereye shadows with its nontoxic formula rich in squalane and shea butter. Phytic acid, derived from rice, gently exfoliates and helps in cell turnover, so skin can breathe and achieve that natural glow. Check out what made this a TGT 2022 reader favorite!
Best For | Hydrating
Natural & Organic | Persian silk tree, hibiscus flower acids, oat extract
Price | $19 for .5 oz
Looking for an ethical and sustainable eye cream that is also affordable? Look no further! cocokind is not only formulated from natural ingredients but the brand is also available at big box stores at lower price points. The revitalizing eye cream uses powerful plant-based ingredients like hibiscus flower acids, a natural source of AHAs for gentle exfoliation, while oat extract locks in the skin’s moisture barrier for a rejuvenating, plumping effect.
Best For | Dull eyes
Natural & Organic | Natural & organic ingredients, fragrance-free
Price | $58 for .58 fl oz
OSEA’s Ocean Eyes Age-Defying Eye Serum is that product guaranteed to see real results— there’s a reason it was voted a TGT reader favorite in 2022! With a blend of organic seaweed, hyaluronic acid, and peptides, this serum rolls on cool and is absorbed into the skin without leaving behind any greasy residue. Not only will you feel refreshed, but you’ll decrease the look of dark circles, fine lines, and puffiness. Plus, knowing that it’s cruelty-free, vegan, and made sustainably in California will turn you into a life-long user.
5. True Botanicals
Best For | Brightening
Price | $78 for .5 oz
For a luxurious, plant-based eye cream free from fillers, True Botanicals is it. Their Resurrection Radiance Eye Cream is clinically proven to address dark circles, puffiness, and even wrinkles with their innovative natural formula. With tree bark, coffee, and licorice extracts and anti-inflammatory turmeric, this powerful cream rejuvenates tired eyes without any of the waxes, shimmers, or silicones in other formulas. Combine this cream with their eye serum and see the skin around your eyes brighten before your, well, eyes. 👀 ✨
6. Juice Beauty
Best For | Fine lines & dark circles
Natural & Organic | Certified organic ingredients, GMO- & synthetic fragrance-free
Price | $50 for .5 oz
For a rich gel eye cream packed with organic ingredients to address your fine lines and dark circles, Juice Beauty’s Stem Cellular Anti-Wrinkle Eye Treatment got your back. Essential fatty acids from organic jojoba oil and evening primrose oil combine with deeply moisturizing shea butter for a high performance cream that smooths and brightens your skin. Juice Beauty ships using FSC certified paper, and subscriptions are available. Sign us up!
7. Ursa Major
Best For | Hydration & skin texture
Natural & Organic | Clean ingredients, certified plastic negative, vegan, cruelty-free
Price | $56 for .5 oz
For a rich and dense eye cream that’ll plump and smooth any texture around the delicate eye area, turn to Ursa Major’s Forest Alchemy Eye Cream. This velvety eye balm feels thick and luxurious and keeps your under eyes smooth and hydrated all day long. Made with unique and powerful ingredients like chaga to limit hyperpigmentation and wild birch, which contains over 17 amino acids, your eye region will thank you for keeping it healthy and moisturized. Use sparingly as a little goes a long way!
8. Tata Harper
Best For | Plumping & moisturizing
Natural & Organic | Natural & organic ingredients, Eco-Cert Certified
Price | $130 for .5 oz
A little goes a long way with Tata Harper’s Refillable Restorative Eye Crème. This super-hydrating, multi-correctional formula is made with 30 high-performance botanical ingredients: 100 percent are natural, and 66 percent are organic. Using olive oil, lavender, and mango, this eye cream can plump, hydrate, and de-puff in just a few weeks. Formulated, handcrafted, and packaged in Vermont, you’ll rest easy knowing this cream is made ethically using eco-friendly practices— like the refillable, sustainable container! Say hello to healthy, supple skin full of elasticity.
Best For | Firming & smoothing
Natural & Organic | Squalane, pink marine algae, paracress extract, and sugarcane
Price | $56 for .5 oz
Winner of a 2020 Allure Best in Beauty award, Biossance’s Squalane + Marine Algae Eye Cream is a champion for us, too. This EWG-approved formula uses squalane sourced from renewable sugarcane, pink marine algae, and paracress extract, developed in a Green Lab Platinum Certified facility. Consumers love how it doesn’t irritate sensitive eyes, works perfectly under makeup, and visibly improves complexion in no time.
10. Nourish Organic
Best For | Tired eyes
Natural & Organic | USDA Certified organic ingredients, non-GMO, gluten-free
Price | $23 for .5 oz
Move over toast, we’ve got a new use for avocado! Nourish Organic’s Renewing & Hydrating Eye Treatment is packed with avocado and argan oils to nourish the delicate skin around your eyes. If you’re in need of a little R&R, it also helps de-puff, smooth, firm, and brighten under-eye circles. As a member of 1% for the Planet, Nourish donates at least one percent of its annual sales to sustainability causes. So not only will your eyes feel revived, so will your soul knowing this cream is as good as it gets.